Everyone's Talking About That Fly That Landed on Mike Pence's Hair

Colton Underwood is returning to the small screen as the co-host of a new Hulu reality show, Are You My First?, centered around virgins finding love — and lust. The former Bachelorette star is the face of the latest show, with another star of The Bachelor universe, Kaitlyn Bristowe, joining the streaming service on August 18.

Underwood, who declared he was a virgin during his stint on The Bachelorette and came out as gay in 2021, will be at the helm of the reality show that claims to have the "largest, hottest group of virgins ever assembled" as they "search for intimacy, love — and maybe their first — in a tropical paradise designed just for them," the official logline reads.

It continues, "For the first time, they’re free to explore their connections without judgment, allowing these sexy young singles to embark on a heated yet heartfelt journey packed with romantic dates, revealing challenges, and new love interests eager to find 'the one.' Who will find that special someone? And who will go home hot, bothered, and heartbroken?”

The show comes from the producers behind Queer Eye and Love Island, so fans can expect some drama. Are You My First? also marks Underwood's first time on the hosting side of reality television, after his prior stint as a contestant.

He will have help from his co-host, who at least has one hosting gig under her belt after co-hosting Season 17 and The Bachelorette alongside fellow former Bachelorette Tayshia Adams. Underwood took time off to focus on building his relationship with his husband, Jordan C. Brown, after their marriage in 2023, and in October 2024, the couple welcomed their first child, Bishop.